Similar Posts

13 Comments

  1. In my testing just now, between Windows 10 and the latest OS X, absolutely no information is retained cross-platform and none of it, including tags, shows up in Photoshop either.

    The way I did it was add text to the Comments field via Properties in Windows, then emailed it my wife and checked Get Info on her Mac. The text was nowhere to be found. So I added new different text to the Comments and the Tags field on the Mac, and emailed it back to myself. I opened the file on Windows and none of the Mac text was there, but the original text I typed on Windows was. Then I opened the file in Photoshop CC on Windows and none of the text from any attempt was visible in the EXIF or anywhere else using File Info in Photoshop.

    It’s not your fault, obviously, but this really sucks from any kind of information systems point of view.

    1. Agreed, it stinks when you go to so much effort to tag files and the data doesn’t go along with the file. I experienced similar problems back in the XP days, but it did seem to work with Windows 8 for my testing. It could be that this capability is broken in Windows 10, or that another step — such as exporting or using Save As — is required.

      I was so frustrated with losing metadata that I switched to Adobe Lightroom for all my digital file tagging and organizing. It works cross-platform and gives me all the basic editing features that I need. I join you in wishing the operating system did the same thing.

  2. In my testing just now, between Windows 10 and the latest OS X, absolutely no information is retained cross-platform and none of it, including tags, shows up in Photoshop either.

    It’s not your fault, obviously, but this really sucks from any kind of information systems point of view.

    1. Chuck, you’ve hit on one of the problems with adding metadata. Typically files need to be “exported” for the metadata to “stick” but sometimes the operating systems just don’t play nicely.

  3. I just use the Paint program to write captions below photos. Just pull down on the resizing dot on the bottom of photo and use the Text “A”, then write in as much info as I want. Pull it down far enough that there is plenty of space to write, then when you’re finished writing, use the resizing dot to shorten the photo just enough to remove the white space at the bottom and still show your caption.

  4. When you add metadata on a MAC using spotlight comments section as shown above, does that information transfer when you send the photo to a PC? I’ve tried it and I can’t find the metadata I added but maybe I’m looking in the wrong spot on the PC. I have been able to add metadata on my MAC using Preview and then having that visible on the PC, but that is more cumbersome. Suggestions?

    1. Hi Cat,
      Yes. I tested this again to confirm, but yes, the keywords added in Spotlight do transfer and show up in the PC Photo Viewer. I did another test to see how and what metadata would transfer, if at all, from Windows to Mac. I will post screenshots of my experiment tomorrow on the blog. Thanks for a great question.

      1. I haven’t been able to enter caption data in Mac that shows up on a PC or in any other software. If you’ve figured that out, I’d love to know! Thanks!

      2. Alison, I’ve found that it’s all trial-and-error with metadata. And to make things worse, system and software updates can break features and change actions. Sorry not to be more helpful. My best advice is to move to a photo management program like Adobe Lightroom that offers true metadata tagging that DOES stick.

Comments are closed.